Shopping Cart
Quick view
Search for products on our site
See more


                Load image into Gallery viewer, Cheesecake

                Load image into Gallery viewer, Cheesecake

                Load image into Gallery viewer, Cheesecake

                Load image into Gallery viewer, Cheesecake
On Sale


She is marvelous. She is decadent. She is the crown jewel of the Carnegie Deli menu. This velvety classic is steeped in New York tradition and triple-baked atop a perfect cookie dough crust. Each cheesecake is individually handmade to achieve satin perfection. Yes, it takes a lot of work and time to make each cheesecake, but the finished product is well worth the effort. It’s heaven. Pure heaven. Grab a fork.


  • (1) Carnegie Deli Plain Cheesecake (8-inch)
  • Each cheesecake weighs approximately 4.5 pounds and serves about 10-12 people.


Cheesecakes can be stored in the refrigerator out of the plastic wrap (preferably in an airtight container) for up to 5 days, or in the freezer in the original packaging for up to 6 months. Once your cake is home, it can be portioned then frozen. Pack the cake in an airtight container or plastic wrap to protect against freezer burn.


  • To thaw, remove cake from plastic wrap and place cake in refrigerator overnight in an airtight container.
  • Allow cheesecake to come to room temperature by sitting out for 3 to 4 hours before serving.
  • To slice, you will need a knife, hot water and a paper towel or clean dish towel. To get a clean slice, run the knife under hot water. Cut the cake, then wipe knife with a towel and repeat.


    • Each order purchased through Carnegie Deli is made fresh and shipped direct. 
    • All orders are shipped via UPS.
    • Depending on your location your package will ship UPS Ground or UPS Two-Day Air.
    • Each product sold is packaged individually and shipped in its own container to ensure freshness.  
    • "Standard" shipping is included in the price of the product.  
    • “Expedited” shipping is an extra charge of $25 per product.  This will upgrade your shipping to either UPS Overnight or UPS Two-Day Air (based on location)
    • Orders are processed at 9:00 AM E.S.T every Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday.  If an order is received after 9:00 AM, it will be marked to ship the next available shipping day.
    • Orders are shipped Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday.
    • Orders are not able to be delivered to P.O. Boxes. 
    • Orders shipped to Alaska & Hawaii via overnight will incur an additional $45 charge.
  1. -$-79.00
  2. Regular price $79.00
    ( / )
    Shipping calculated at checkout.